Invalid Audio Buffer Size on Samsung Galaxy

[joelt]

The following works fine on a G1 but gives an error on the Samsung
Galaxy. I was hoping cross-platform support would be better than this.
See error below.

private final static int RATE = 44100;
private final static int CHANNEL_MODE =
AudioFormat.CHANNEL_CONFIGURATION_MONO;
private final static int ENCODING =
AudioFormat.ENCODING_PCM_16BIT;
private AudioRecord recorder_;


public boolean open() {

int bufferSize = 4 * AudioRecord.getMinBufferSize(RATE,
CHANNEL_MODE, ENCODING);
recorder_ = new AudioRecord(AudioSource.MIC, RATE, CHANNEL_MODE,
ENCODING, bufferSize);

last line gives the following on the Samsung Galaxy phone:
11-14 19:04:07.507: ERROR/AndroidRuntime(7617):
java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Invalid audio buffer size.

[joelt]

It is also spitting this out:
WARN/AudioHardwareMSM72XX(1018): getInputBufferSize bad sampling rate:
44100

Is there an API that will tell me which rates it _does_ support? It
doesn't look like it.

Post by joelt
The following works fine on a G1 but gives an error on the Samsung
Galaxy. I was hoping cross-platform support would be better than this.
See error below.
    private final static int RATE = 44100;
    private final static int CHANNEL_MODE =
AudioFormat.CHANNEL_CONFIGURATION_MONO;
    private final static int ENCODING =
AudioFormat.ENCODING_PCM_16BIT;
    private AudioRecord recorder_;
 public boolean open() {
  int bufferSize = 4 * AudioRecord.getMinBufferSize(RATE,
CHANNEL_MODE, ENCODING);
  recorder_ = new AudioRecord(AudioSource.MIC, RATE, CHANNEL_MODE,
ENCODING, bufferSize);
java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Invalid audio buffer size.

[joelt]

Further analysis reveals it only supports an 8k sampling rate. This is
obviously a bug. Where do I file a bug report against the Samsung
phone?

Post by joelt
44100
Is there an API that will tell me which rates it _does_ support? It
doesn't look like it.

Post by joelt
The following works fine on a G1 but gives an error on the Samsung
Galaxy. I was hoping cross-platform support would be better than this.
See error below.
    private final static int RATE = 44100;
    private final static int CHANNEL_MODE =
AudioFormat.CHANNEL_CONFIGURATION_MONO;
    private final static int ENCODING =
AudioFormat.ENCODING_PCM_16BIT;
    private AudioRecord recorder_;
 public boolean open() {
  int bufferSize = 4 * AudioRecord.getMinBufferSize(RATE,
CHANNEL_MODE, ENCODING);
  recorder_ = new AudioRecord(AudioSource.MIC, RATE, CHANNEL_MODE,
ENCODING, bufferSize);
java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Invalid audio buffer size.

[TonyDoc]

Add you bug to the list over at androidforums.com, samsung seem to
have a dreadful android/galaxy support team.

Post by joelt
Further analysis reveals it only supports an 8k sampling rate. This is
obviously a bug. Where do I file a bug report against the Samsung
phone?

Post by joelt
44100
Is there an API that will tell me which rates it _does_ support? It
doesn't look like it.

Post by joelt
The following works fine on a G1 but gives an error on the Samsung
Galaxy. I was hoping cross-platform support would be better than this.
See error below.
    private final static int RATE = 44100;
    private final static int CHANNEL_MODE =
AudioFormat.CHANNEL_CONFIGURATION_MONO;
    private final static int ENCODING =
AudioFormat.ENCODING_PCM_16BIT;
    private AudioRecord recorder_;
 public boolean open() {
  int bufferSize = 4 * AudioRecord.getMinBufferSize(RATE,
CHANNEL_MODE, ENCODING);
  recorder_ = new AudioRecord(AudioSource.MIC, RATE, CHANNEL_MODE,
ENCODING, bufferSize);
java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Invalid audio buffer size.

[niko20]

I hope you are bothering to check for ERROR_BAD_VALUE from the
getMinBufferSize, you can use this to determine if the hardware
supports the settings you want or not.

As far as cross-platform, this is still one of the valid reasons to
check the error codes, I don't think it's possible for us to say all
devices should support all formats, it just common sense.

-niko

Post by TonyDoc
Add you bug to the list over at androidforums.com, samsung seem to
have a dreadful android/galaxy support team.

Post by joelt
Further analysis reveals it only supports an 8k sampling rate. This is
obviously a bug. Where do I file a bug report against the Samsung
phone?

Post by joelt
44100
Is there an API that will tell me which rates it _does_ support? It
doesn't look like it.

Post by joelt
The following works fine on a G1 but gives an error on the Samsung
Galaxy. I was hoping cross-platform support would be better than this.
See error below.
    private final static int RATE = 44100;
    private final static int CHANNEL_MODE =
AudioFormat.CHANNEL_CONFIGURATION_MONO;
    private final static int ENCODING =
AudioFormat.ENCODING_PCM_16BIT;
    private AudioRecord recorder_;
 public boolean open() {
  int bufferSize = 4 * AudioRecord.getMinBufferSize(RATE,
CHANNEL_MODE, ENCODING);
  recorder_ = new AudioRecord(AudioSource.MIC, RATE, CHANNEL_MODE,
ENCODING, bufferSize);
java.lang.IllegalArgumentException: Invalid audio buffer size.